For Those Who Fail - Joaquin Miller
Today is poet speak day.
Curious to find poetry hot spots in the environments I frequent, I started by doing a search for poetry communities in MyBlogLog.
I came across classicpoetryaloud’s community, “Classic Poetry Aloud Index“. He offers poetry readings by podcast. (if you’re not a MyBlogLog member, his official site can be found here)
In his community RSS feed I saw a title to one of his previous podcasts called “For Those Who Fail” by Joaquin Miller.
Joaquin Miller tidbits:
Joaquin Miller was pen name. His real name was Cincinnatus Heine (or Hiner) Miller.
Born in Union County, Indiana on September 8, 1837.
Possibly of German Baptist upbringing.
While young he moved to an Oregon farm with his family.
His occupations included:
Mining camp cook
Lawyer
Judge
Newspaper writer
Pony Express writer
Horse thief
In 1857 he married an Indian woman named Paquita. They had two children.
Miller later married Theresa Dyer in 1862 and had three children with her. They divorced in 1869.
Miller married Abigail Leland in 1879 in New York, New York.
He was jailed for stealing a horse in Shasta County, although there were more than one incident reported.
He spent some time in mining camps then moved to Canyon City, Oregon by 1864 and was elected third Judge of Grant County.
He later lost a seat with the Oregon Supreme Court, experienced another failed marriage, then traveled abroad for some years.
He eventually settled in Oakland, California where he grew fruit and published his various writing (poetry and the like).
Ambrose Bierce (American editorialist, journalist, short-story writer) once called Miller “The greatest-hearted man he ever knew.” yet also said he was “The greatest liar this country ever produced. He cannot, will not, tell the truth.” Miller said, “I always wondered why God made Bierce.”
From 1886 to 1913 (when Miller died) Miller lived in Oakland, in a home he called “The Hights.”
In 1919 “The Hights” was bought by the city and can be found in “Joaquin Miller Park.” It is designated a California Historical Landmark.
Todays Poet Speak poem:
“For Those Who Fail” by Joaquin Miller
“All honor to him who shall win the prize,”
The world has cried for a thousand years;
But to him who tries and who fails and dies,
I give great honor and glory and tears.
O great is the hero who wins a name,
But greater many and many a time,
Some pale-faced fellow who dies in shame,
And lets God finish the thought sublime.
And great is the man with a sword undrawn,
And good is the man who refrains from wine;
But the man who fails and yet fights on,
Lo! he is the twin-born brother of mine!
In “Childrens Literature - a textbook of sources for teachers and teacher training classes” by Charles Madison Curry (published 1921 - original from Harvard University) “For Those Who Fail” is said to suggest ‘the important truth that he who wins popular applause is not usually the one who most deserves to be honored.’
That I believe too.
Extra:
One of Millers most famous poems is “Columbus”:
- “In men whom men condemn as ill
- I find so much of goodness still.
- In men whom men pronounce divine
- I find so much of sin and blot
- I do not dare to draw a line
- Between the two, where God has not.”
Once again, if you’d like to hear classic poetry by podcast, visit “Classic Poetry Aloud Index.”
*Permalink to “For Those Who Fail” podcast*
| 2.5 |




Nature Conservancy feed
March 28th, 2008 at 10:01 am
A friend of mine just emailed me one of your articles from a while back. I read that one a few more. Really enjoy your blog. Thanks.
Jason
March 28th, 2008 at 11:21 am
Intriguing post! I’d like to learn more about Joaquin Miller now. The stories of the lives of poets and writers can be as rich and interesting as the words they pen. “For Those Who Fail” does contain thoughts worth thinking about carefully.
I’m going to be looking for more from Joaquin Miller. Thanks.
March 28th, 2008 at 11:36 am
Jason: Thank you for taking time to comment and for the compliment.
Bill: For Those Who Fail is a tribute to the underdog. Anyone can receive praise upon screaming the words “Look at me aren’t I great?!”
Typically all it takes is a little company from an in-crowd that forgets what humanity is. They seem to be mass promoters of stepping on toes and being hurtful to others on their journey up.
Those that fight for what is most meaningful in life will always be the underdog.
In the end, they prove the strongest because they still fought though it be alone.
March 28th, 2008 at 12:07 pm
Yes, Kimberly. That’s the way that I read it too. As a tribute to the underdog.
March 28th, 2008 at 12:18 pm
Kimberly, many thanks for the mention, and for picking this poem in particular. When it first aired it did not receive as many downloads as I had hoped, perhaps because the title seems negative: ‘For those who fail’. But of course the poem is not about failing and giving up, but carrying on. It deserves wider recognition. Thank you for posting it.
Don
Classic Poetry Aloud
March 28th, 2008 at 12:28 pm
I’m grateful to have found it on your site Don. Thank you.